Here’s what nobody will tell you: the best city isn’t about what it offers. It’s about what you can tolerate. Its flaws need to be flaws you can live with, or even laugh about.
Are you okay with eight months of winter? Then maybe Minneapolis is your jam. Does relentless, cheerful sunshine feel fake and oppressive to you? Avoid Phoenix like the plague. Does a fast-paced city where no one makes eye contact sound isolating, or peacefully anonymous? Your answer to that tells you more than any listicle.
Let me give you some unvarnished, human opinions.
If you dream of a “creative city”
The promise is cheap lofts, gallery openings, and collaborative energy. The reality is often different.
- Portland, Austin, Brooklyn: The ship has sailed. The artists who made those places cool were priced out a decade ago. What’s left is the aesthetic, sold back to you in overpriced condos. It’s a vibe for trust-fund kids and remote tech workers now, not a struggling painter.
- A real contender: Detroit, Michigan. I know, I know. But hear me out. Detroit has scars, and it shows them. That’s what makes it real. You can get a warehouse space for a song. The community is tight-knit and fiercely proud. People are making incredible art, music, and food not because it’s trendy, but because they’re rebuilding something. The winter is brutal. The bureaucracy is frustrating. But it’s authentic. You have to want to be part of a story, not just a resident.
- And a practical Detroit truth: Those gorgeous, vast warehouse lofts? They’re often just empty shells. There’s no attic, no basement, no garage. Where do you put your Christmas ornaments? Your old love letters? Your snow tires? Every creative person I know there uses a storage unit as their collective basement. It’s a non-negotiable. It’s where the practical stuff lives so the living space can stay an ever-evolving studio. It’s cheap, it’s secure, and it means you can keep making art without drowning in your own life-admin.
If you want “good schools and a yard”
The dream of the suburbs. But which ones? They’re not all plastic and despair.
- The Generic Blob: Any suburb with a name like “The Preserve at River Oaks” probably has no soul. It’s all vinyl siding and chain restaurants. The schools are good, but the culture is… shopping.
- A real gem: Older, inner-ring suburbs. Look at places like Maplewood, Missouri (near St. Louis) or Berkeley, Illinois (near Chicago). These towns were built in the 1920s-50s. They have mature trees, sidewalks, quirky local diners, and train lines into the city. The houses have character (and weird bathrooms). The communities are established. You trade a slightly longer commute and possibly smaller closets for a sense of place. Your kids can ride bikes to a friend’s house. You know your neighbors.
The family-life secret
These charming old houses have tiny closets. Like, “hold five shirts” tiny. And basements that smell faintly of damp earth. Family life generates stuff—a torrent of it. Where do the grandparents’ heirlooms go? The baby gear between kids? The patio furniture in January? I’ve helped three friends move in these areas. They all rent a modest storage unit. It’s the only way to preserve the charm of their home without it becoming a chaotic stuffed animal prison. It’s the overflow valve for family life.
If you’re chasing sunshine and a fresh start
The lure of the Sun Belt is powerful. But it’s not all palm trees and margaritas.
- Phoenix, Las Vegas: These are cities of extremes. The heat isn’t just hot; it’s a wall of oppressive energy from May to October that pins you indoors. Everything is new, which means everything feels a bit temporary, a bit rootless. It can be strangely lonely.
- A different angle: Albuquerque, New Mexico. This is high desert. It has seasons. It has jaw-dropping sunsets over the Sandia Mountains that look like the sky is on fire. It has a deep, tricultural history (Native, Hispanic, Anglo) that gives it a soul you can feel in the food and the architecture. It’s slower. It’s poorer in parts. It’s weird in the best way (hello, annual International Balloon Fiesta!). It’s for people who want the Southwest aesthetic without the Arizona ego or Texas size.
The Albuquerque quirk: Adobe-style homes are beautiful. They also often have flat roofs and very little built-in storage. And in that dry climate, you have two completely different sets of everything: summer gear and winter gear. Where do you put the space heater when it’s 90 degrees? The heavy blankets? A storage unit here isn’t for junk; it’s for seasonal rotation. It’s a standard part of home logistics, like having a water softener.
So what’s the actual step?
- Identify your non-negotiable flaw. What can you truly, honestly live with? Gray skies? Brutal heat? High taxes? No good bagels?
- Visit in the worst season. Go in February. Go in August. Don’t go on a vacation. Go on a Thursday.
- Talk to a bartender or a barista. Tell them you’re thinking of moving. Ask them what they hate about it. Their answer will be more valuable than anything you read.
And finally, understand this: making a home is a process of accumulation and editing. You’ll collect things that matter, and you’ll need space for the in-between. Wherever you land, having a little extra room for your life’s “loading dock” can make all the difference in turning a new city into your city. We see it every day—people storing pieces of their past while they build their future. It’s a human thing, not a storage thing.
Now get off the computer. Go think about what you really want your Tuesdays to feel like. That’s your answer.
0 Comments